Original Air Date: 02 October 2008
Sam works his mojo on a demon, who taunts Sam and refuses to give up Lilith. Dean is hiding in the shadows, and Ruby looks on –with disturbing approval. Dean walks in on Sam and Ruby. Ruby greets Dean, and he attacks her, pulling her own knife on her. After the fight, Ruby helps the injured and newly exorcised man out of the room. Dean walks off, angry.
Back in their motel room, Dean walks in, and grabs his stuff. Sam, who is already settled into the room, tries to get Dean to talk to him. Dean just punches him –twice. Sam is unable to convince Dean that he’s doing a good thing by saving possessd people. Considering the hundreds they’ve lost over the years, this is good. Even with Ruby’s knife, the human dies. Sam argues that his way merely sends the demon back to Hell. Dean is unimpressed, especially with how far Sam has gone “off the reservation.” He tells Sam that, if he didn’t know him, he’d hunt him. Dean questions his brother, asking, if everything is so great, why did Sam lie. He also asks why an angel told him to stop Sam.
A man is eating ravenously, as his wife asks, “Jack, are you stoned?” She questions his non-stop eating, but he dismisses it. As Jack brushes his teeth, bone cracking noises come from his back, while he reels in understandable pain.